What To Do When a Teammate is Off

How to Reset the Field Without Falling Apart

You’ve seen it happen. One player has a miss, gets frustrated, or freezes under pressure. And suddenly the whole team feels off. Communication drops. Tension builds. And a game that was going smoothly starts to unravel.

So what’s really going on when one player’s struggle affects the entire field? And more importantly, what can you do to reset the energy before momentum is lost?

The Ripple is Real

In sports, energy is contagious. Whether it’s confidence or chaos, athletes pick up on each other’s emotional states. Teams don’t just sync up physically. They sync emotionally and energetically too. That’s because of two core mechanisms:

Mirror Neurons

These are specialized brain cells that activate when we see someone else perform an action or express an emotion.

  • When one athlete stiffens, misses, or panics—others feel it too, often unconsciously.

  • It’s why yawns are contagious. Why tension spreads fast. Why one athlete’s confidence can lift the whole team.

Team Field Coherence

This is the invisible energetic rhythm created during shared play.

  • When a team is in sync, there’s fluid movement, trust, and what feels like "flow."

  • When the field coherence breaks because of stress, miscommunication, or pressure, players start scrambling, disconnecting, or freezing.

When one athlete’s nervous system spikes into fight, flight, or freeze, it can disrupt that field and the team loses its flow. It’s how nervous systems work in groups.

The good news? Field awareness and reset tools can bring that coherence back fast.

Why One Player’s Off Day Feels like Everyone’s

Most athletes don’t say, “I feel dysregulated.” But their body and behavior do. Here’s how it shows up on the field:

Physical Cues

  • Awkward timing

  • Stiff posture or body tension

  • Fidgeting or pacing

  • Freeze response (sudden stillness)

  • Shaky hands

  • Clenched fists or jaw tension

  • Shallow breathing or breath holding

  • Sudden drop in speed or intensity

  • Mouth open or dry mouth

Mental/Emotional Cues

  • Confused decision-making

  • Can’t process instructions

  • Overthinking simple plays

  • Loss of confidence mid-play

  • Tunnel vision or stuck focus

  • Rigid, repetitive thinking

  • Can’t recover after a mistake

  • Emotional shutdown

  • Flat affect or numbed reactions

Relational/Team Cues

  • Silence or over-talking

  • Avoids or breaks eye contact

  • Withdrawing from team huddles

  • Stops calling for the ball or making signals

  • Irritability or short fuse with teammates

  • Misreads tone or body language

  • Refuses support or help

  • “Ghosting” (mentally checked out)

  • Looks to bench or sideline for escape or validation

Self Talk Isn’t Always Enough

You’ve probably heard advice like, “Just tell yourself to shake it off” or “Take a breath and move on.” But here’s the thing: When the nervous system is flooded, words don’t land because survival energy needs movement to reset.

This is especially true for youth athletes. In high-pressure moments, their bodies are wired to do, not think.

What actually helps regulate emotions:

  • A visible breath and shoulder roll

  • A quick shakeout or foot tap

  • A return-to-focus phrase paired with movement (e.g., clap + “next point”)

  • A gesture like a thumbs up, chest tap, or grounding posture

Teach movement-based resets first. Then the mind can catch up.

You Don’t Have to Fix Someone Else’s Energy

When a teammate is off, it’s easy to feel pressure to fix them. But that’s not your job. Your job is to regulate yourself first and use your tools to help reset the field, not absorb other’s dysregulation.

Here’s what that looks like in real time:

  • Instead of: “They’re spiraling. I need to get them back.”

  • Try: “I’m steady. I’m clear. Let me be the anchor.”

The fastest way to shift the team is to regulate your own energy first. Then, lead by example, not pressure.

Try this on the court or field:

  • Take one visible deep breath (let them see you reset)

  • Walk calmly back to your position. Don’t rush.

  • Hold calm, steady eye contact with a teammate

  • Use a slow, intentional hand signal (like a thumbs up, chest tap, or “reset” motion)

  • Let your body language say “I’m grounded” (relaxed shoulders, strong posture, steady presence)

You don’t have to fix your teammate’s energy. You just have to hold your own. Let your energy be the stronger regulator that helps get the field back in alignment.

When the field feels off, it’s not just the coach’s job to bring the team back. Every athlete can help, but not everyone resets the same way.

In the AthELITES system, we teach four Reset Roles. These are simple ways teammates can stabilize the field using their own energy and strengths. These roles don’t need training to start using. Just read the play, pick one, and lead by example.

Here’s how they work:

Troubleshoot the Tilt. What to do when you see…

  • IGNITER

    Use when:

    The team feels flat, sluggish, or low-energy.

    What to do:

    Clap, cheer, or do something physical to get attention

    Shout a cue like: “Let’s go!” or “Bring it back!”

    Use bold body language—movement sparks momentum

    Your role:

    You’re the spark that lights the reset. Your energy helps the team re-engage and re-ignite.

  • CONNECTOR

    Use when:

    Teammates seem disconnected, irritable, or uncertain.

    What to do:

    Make strong eye contact

    Offer a fist bump, shoulder tap, or quick check-in

    Say: “We’ve got each other.” or “Let’s pull together.”

    Your role:

    You rebuild trust. Your presence reminds the team that no one’s alone.

  • COMMANDER

    Use when:

    Things feel chaotic—missed calls, scrambling, no one taking the lead.

    What to do:

    Call for a quick team huddle or reset

    Use clear, firm words: “Clean play.” “Focus.” “One task at a time.”

    Reinforce roles and rhythm

    Your role:

    You bring structure and leadership. Your clarity cuts through the noise.

  • ANCHOR

    Use when:

    Emotions are high, panic is setting in, or teammates are spiraling.

    What to do:

    Take a visible deep breath

    Speak slowly and calmly: “We’re okay.” “One point at a time.”

    Hold steady eye contact or offer a calm grounding gesture

    Your role:

    You stabilize the field. Your calm helps others settle and reset.

Coach and Captain Reset Tools

When the field feels off, captains need to stabilize themselves first before trying to rally the team. Here’s how to do that in less than 30 seconds—without needing a timeout:

  1. Plant Your Feet


    Feel your feet on the ground. Let your weight settle downward. This settles your nervous system so you can respond instead of react.

  2. Drop Your Breath


    Inhale low and slow through your nose, into your belly. Exhale through your mouth like you’re fogging a mirror. (No one has to know you’re doing it—just one breath can flip your nervous system back to calm.)

  3. Widen Your Gaze


    Instead of tunnel-visioning on the ball or one teammate, soften your eyes and take in the whole court or field. This is a known neurological cue for "safety" and brings your awareness back to the moment.

  4. Choose One Anchor Phrase


    In your head (or aloud if needed), drop a steadying cue:

    • “Steady.”

    • “We’re here.”

    • “Next ball.”

    • “Reset and go.”

  5. Lead with Body, Not Just Voice


    Your team will mirror what you radiate. Calm posture, strong eye contact, and steady energy speak louder than commands.

SIDEBAR: For Parents Watching form the Sidelines

Sometimes it’s hard to watch the energy shift and not say something or yell out. But your nervous system plays a role too.

Here’s how to support your athlete’s field without disrupting it:

DO:

  • Stay calm in your body. Slow your own breath

  • Use silent visual anchors (hand on heart, head nod, thumb up)

  • Remind yourself: They know how to come back

AVOID:

  • Yelling instructions

  • Shaming or overly emotional reactions

  • Dissecting every mistake after the game

The best reset starts when you model grounded energy.

Join the Reset Locker™

Your personal vault of game ready tools to calm your system, clear your field, and reset fast—on your terms. Each month we’ll drop members only tools to your inbox, absolutely free.